Deborah Walker
Nov 23, 2023 - 10:10

Joe Mixon vs David Montgomery: Week 12 Fantasy Outlook

Week 12 of fantasy football is approaching, and the decision between Joe Mixon and David Montgomery is pivotal. Start Montgomery.

As we approach Week 12 of the fantasy football season, the stakes are high as many leagues are heading into the playoffs. One of the key decisions facing fantasy football managers is which running back to start in their lineup. Running backs are often considered the safest point scorers, and with the playoffs looming, the pressure is on to make the right choice.

In this scenario, the decision comes down to Joe Mixon and David Montgomery. Both running backs have had strong performances this season, but with only room for one in the lineup, the choice is crucial. Let's take a closer look at each player and their upcoming matchups to determine the best option for Week 12.

Joe Mixon of the Cincinnati Bengals has seen a surge in his fantasy value as the 2023 season has progressed. Despite a slow start, Mixon has put up impressive numbers, averaging 14 points per game and ranking as RB10 in PPR scoring. With 605 rushing yards, four touchdowns, and 31 receptions for 188 yards and another score, Mixon has become a versatile and reliable option for fantasy managers. The Bengals' recent loss of quarterback Joe Burrow to injury has raised questions about the team's offensive dynamics, but Mixon's potential as a safety blanket for the new quarterback cannot be overlooked.

On the other hand, David Montgomery of the Detroit Lions has been a pleasant surprise this season, ranking as RB24 in PPR scoring with an average of 17.2 points per game. Despite missing time due to a rib cartilage injury, Montgomery has rushed for 577 yards and eight touchdowns, showcasing his ability to make an impact on the field. The Lions' strong rushing attack, combined with an upcoming matchup against the Green Bay Packers, makes Montgomery an appealing option for Week 12.

When comparing the two players' matchups, the Pittsburgh Steelers, who the Bengals will face, have allowed 127.7 rushing yards per game, while the Green Bay Packers, who the Lions will face, have allowed 134.7 rushing yards per game. Both teams rank in the bottom half of the league in terms of defending against fantasy running backs, creating favorable opportunities for both Mixon and Montgomery.

Ultimately, our start/sit analyzer recommends starting David Montgomery over Joe Mixon in Week 12. Montgomery's involvement in a strong rushing attack, combined with the uncertainty surrounding the Bengals' offense after losing their starting quarterback, tips the scales in his favor. As the fantasy football season heats up, making informed decisions about lineup choices becomes increasingly important, and in this case, Montgomery emerges as the preferred option for Week 12.